This topic fascinates me, so allow me to explore it a little bit.
It kinda makes me laugh when people panic or speculate about what the awful, corrupt Russians might do with our LJ entries. It's actually funny to me that some are worried that the Russians are going to "spy" on their data.
Oy.
LJ entries are not secure, and they never were. Anything you post on LJ (or any other non-encrypted site) is going to travel via multiple Internet pipes, between your computer, an ISP, and get relayed beyond through several other layers that are (surprise!) run by corporations. Your LJ post will exist on multiple servers where it will be backed-up and published. Next, search engines will index and cache it. Think you can delete a post and it'll go away? Think again. It still lives in backup tapes and caches. Once it's out there, it's out there.
Even if your post is Friends-only, it's probably not being encrypted during transmission. And it's still accessible by employees of LiveJournal (or SixApart or SUP or whoever.) And we've probably all been betrayed by so-called LJ friends who leak the posts that you've marked as Friends-only.
Even if you've taken steps to
call-off the search robots, your journal may still be crawled by rogue search engines (or by people who just don't like you, if you're unlucky.) There are even
some websites out there who exist solely to index blog entries.
I guess what I'm saying is this: no matter what corporation owns LiveJournal, your posts are never going to be completely 100% secure from prying eyes.
I've been doing some further reading, and found some interesting bits here and there.
From Wired.com:
- The company will build an Abuse Team that follows the American model of responding to complaints, rather than taking proactive measures.
- [CEO of SixApart] Barak Berkowitz says LiveJournal has never claimed to be secure from organized eavesdropping. Traffic on the wire is not encrypted, and the Russian government is perfectly capable of monitoring Russia's corner of the internet. "If people have some illusion that cleartext internet traffic can't be read ... (it's easier) to read that way than get it from Sup," he says.
- The stakes in the SUP deal are high for both parties... a wrong move in a region like Russia could damage [the LiveJournal] brand worldwide. The consequences of failure would be even greater for SUP, which plans its LiveJournal deal as the start of a major online media play.
From [LiveJournal creator] Brad Fitzpatrick's LiveJournal:
- "They want to throw a lot of resources at LiveJournal in terms of product development and engineers."
From ZDNet:
- LiveJournal Russia [already] represents 28 percent of the global monthly LiveJournal audience. Only about 20 percent of registered members are in the U.S.
- The new LiveJournal company, based in San Francisco, will have an advisory board consisting of industry experts and members of the LiveJournal community, including Brad Fitzpatrick, the founder of LiveJournal and who is now at Google.
From LJ_2008 community:
- LiveJournal’s rules on freedom of expression remain absolutely unchanged.
- Among planned improvements in 2008: improve user-friendliness of home and portal pages, optimize navigation, create widget functionality, establish clear policy guidelines, increase service speed and performance, and increase certain limits for Basic and Plus accounts.
So maybe we'll see some improvements around here.
Do I think LJ is the best blogging site out there? No. I much prefer Typepad or Vox or Wordpress. But I think LiveJournal has superior features for interaction with friends.
I also have to chuckle when people call the Russian government and corporations "corrupt." Are some of them corrupt? Yes. Maybe even a lot. Just as governments and corporations can be corrupt in
any country. (America is not immune, either. Think Enron, Halliburton, Watergate, and maybe even some rigged elections. And don't get me started on individual politicians.)
There's even been a suggestion that this is just the next level of outsourcing and exporting business from the United States. Listen folks. Globalization is happening. I reject the notion that
all globalization is bad. To even suggest defection (pun intended) from LiveJournal simply because it'll be owned by a Russian corporation is just silly. T-Mobile is owned by Deutsche Telecom. Chrysler, Shell, Best Foods, Pillsbury, Ralston Purina, Firestone... all are owned by overseas companies now. Are you going to boycott all of them too?
Until I see abuse, I'm staying-put.